≡ Menu

Lao Gu on Rubio, the ICC, and World Government: “Don’t Quote Law to Men Who Carry Swords”

Writing from Guangdong, Austrian-school writer Lao Gu takes as his starting point Marco Rubio’s Nov. 13 keynote at the Federalist Society’s National Lawyers Convention, where Rubio, warning the International Criminal Court off Americans, invoked Pompey’s line about not quoting laws to men with swords. Setting aside whether Netanyahu is a war criminal, Lao Gu argues that Rubio’s line states a basic truth—the international order is anarchic—and that, judged as a means, the ICC fails even on its own terms: it cannot stop wars, compensate victims, or meaningfully deter rulers. Worse, a global court is a step toward world government, and a worldwide monopoly on coercion and redistribution would be far more dangerous than the anarchy among states we have now. In a Hoppean vein, he concludes that more fragmented governance means smaller catastrophes.

From Austrian School Lao Gu, “Rubio: Don’t Quote Law to Men Who Carry Swords,” Ludwig von Mises Substack (Nov. 16, 2026), translated from the Chinese original:

On 13 November 2026, Marco Rubio delivered the keynote at the Federalist Society’s National Lawyers Convention in Washington, D.C. In his speech he quoted a line — the original English being:

“Stop quoting laws to men with swords.”

The line is attributed to the Roman general Pompey. Roughly: don’t come at those of us who hold the sword with your statute books.

Who was he addressing? The International Criminal Court. He was warning the ICC not to try to enforce its rulings against American citizens, and he called the court a “fake tribunal” and a “rogue court.”

There was a trigger for this. The ICC had issued an arrest warrant for Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu over the Gaza conflict. The Trump administration treated this as a provocation against a key ally and vowed to “dismantle” the court’s operations.

I’m not here to argue whether Netanyahu is a war criminal or a hero. That’s not today’s subject. The subject is the line itself.

Doesn’t it sound deeply unpleasant? I’ve got the sword — you’re going to lecture me about legal clauses? What’s that going to do? Lock me up?

And yet that is simply the reality. Rubio’s words lay bare a fact about the world: at bottom, the international order is anarchic. The ICC and similar bodies are attempts to dissolve that anarchy — to build a supranational authority with the power to administer justice and, in principle, to arrest anyone a domestic legal system can’t touch.

And they’ve partly pulled it off.

On 7 March 2025, the ICC’s Pre-Trial Chamber I issued an arrest warrant for Rodrigo Duterte, charging him with murder as a crime against humanity, tied to his “war on drugs.” On 11 March 2025, upon returning to Manila International Airport, Duterte was detained by Philippine authorities acting on the ICC warrant. He is still held in The Hague, awaiting trial.

Putin and Netanyahu are both on the wanted list now, likewise charged with war crimes.

So — is this a good thing?

A lot of people talk endlessly about justice. They say justice will prevail. They almost wish for a god above mankind who will wipe out everything they judge unjust, and then they’ll feel the world is set right. The ICC is, for some, one instrument for realising that world-government ideal.

Well, sorry — it isn’t a good thing.

Someone will immediately retort: but if someone upholds justice, if someone can bring to book the people domestic law can’t reach, how is that not justice? Don’t you lot believe in natural law? Don’t you say property rights are supreme? If someone violates property, why shouldn’t he be dealt with?

Here we meet the usual misunderstanding of the Austrian school.

The Austrians don’t argue about ends. They argue about means. Of course justice should be done. But the ICC is a means, and what we have to assess is whether that means is sound — whether it actually reduces tyranny and restrains rulers.

As Rubio put it: men with swords couldn’t care less about your legal text.

In antiquity, yes. But in the modern era too there have been plenty of tyrants, many of whom died in their beds. They were openly the men with swords; no domestic law could touch them. Did the ICC’s warrants against Netanyahu and Putin stop the Gaza war or the Russia–Ukraine war? Not in the slightest. Beyond a bit of public-relations noise, they’ve changed almost nothing about what either man does.

What are police for? Two things. First, to stop the crime in progress. Second, to find the offender afterwards. And a court exists to assign blame and decide punishment and restitution.

The ICC can’t stop the crime in progress. As for finding the offender afterwards — if the offender is a head of state, restitution is meaningless. Why? Even if the politician looted the treasury, he still can’t pay for the lives lost and the wealth destroyed. A serial killer’s worst case might be dozens of victims. The Russia–Ukraine and Gaza wars run to hundreds of thousands, millions, and the destroyed wealth starts in the billions and runs to trillions of dollars. There is no way to pay it back. Get it?

If you owe far more than you could ever repay, the bank won’t lend to you in the first place — because it knows you can’t bear the liability, so it prices you out beforehand. In private law between ordinary people, we try not to hand massive liabilities to a single individual. Suppose you keep £100m of antiques at home, and you hire a junior security guard to watch them, signing a contract that says he’ll compensate you if anything goes missing. What happens? The contract is unenforceable — he can’t pay. He can’t carry that responsibility.

So in private disputes, people don’t only rely on the law after the fact. They prepare beforehand, to avoid catastrophic loss for which no one can make them whole.

That’s why people who say “justice must prevail, we need a world government to try every war criminal” don’t understand what justice is. Justice isn’t an empty slogan. Legally, it means the victim receives compensation proportionate to the harm — an eye for an eye, yes, but also restoration for the victim. So tell me: can the ICC compensate any specific victim? It cannot.

Justice systems have another function: deterrence. The idea that if you commit the crime, punishment waits for you, so you think twice. That’s a side-effect of adjudication.

Does it work? For ordinary people, reasonably. For politicians, hardly at all. Because most politicians already face far harsher deterrence than anything the ICC offers — the retaliation of their political rivals. Look at South Korean presidents: how many ended well? Assassination, frame-ups, coups, house arrest, impeachment, character assassination — the toolkit is endless. Political competition is brutal and has no rules. Was Trump safe? He nearly got sent to prison by Biden. Dozens of criminal counts were stacked on him. You think he’s frightened of the ICC’s deterrent? In this line of work you make your peace with the possibility of physical elimination. Prison is the least of it. Kennedy was assassinated, wasn’t he?

So I’m not saying we reject justice. I’m saying the ICC, as a means, fails even on its own terms.

Read more>>

Related

  1. Hans-Hermann Hoppe, The Economics and Ethics of Private Property: Studies in Political Economy and Philosophy (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2006 [1993]), pp. 407–408. [↩]

Discuss on X

Subscribe to PFS recaps

New articles, pages, and podcasts. Choose how often you hear from us.

Delivery

You can change delivery or unsubscribe at any time.

Creative Commons License
Except where otherwise noted, the content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.