≡ Menu

Lao Gu on China’s $1 Trillion Trade Surplus

Writing from Guangdong, Austrian-school writer Lao Gu challenges the conventional view that China’s record trade surplus—more than $1 trillion in 2025, and on track for another record in 2026—is a sign of national success. Nations don’t trade; people do. Trade is ultimately barter between individuals, money is just the intermediary, and a surplus means Chinese producers shipped out real goods in exchange for paper claims they cannot consume. He goes on to argue that the surplus is driven not by efficiency but by policy—an undervalued renminbi plus tariffs, VAT, and excise taxes on imports—and amounts to a subsidy to foreign consumers at the expense of Chinese ones.

From Austrian School Lao Gu, “A $1 Trillion Trade Surplus,” Ludwig von Mises Substack (Nov. 16, 2026), translated from the Chinese original:

Let’s start with a number.

In 2025, China’s goods trade surplus came in at $1,188.9 billion — the first time in history it has ever crossed the $1 trillion mark, up another 19.8% on 2024. In the first 10 months of 2026 alone, the surplus has already reached $1.04 trillion, and the full-year figure will almost certainly set yet another record.

In the headlines, a number like this usually comes dressed up with words like “resilience,” “strength,” and “shrugging off the tariff war.”

But if you run the sums from a different angle, the conclusion flips completely.

Two years running at this scale isn’t winning — it’s a loss. Not “we sold too much so we won,” but “we bought back too little, so we lost.”

Because so many people have grown up inside decades of surpluses, they’ll say: money came in, how can that be a loss?

If you’ve got even a basic grasp of economic theory, you’ll see that international trade and trade between two individuals are fundamentally the same thing — and once you see that, the accounting becomes very clear.

I

 

Mercantilism left us with a deep-rooted illusion: export is “earning,” import is “losing,” surplus is “winning,” deficit is “losing.” The country is treated like a company — exports are revenue, imports are cost, and the surplus is profit.

And yet — the trade balance is descriptive, not normative.

What does that mean? A country can run a trade deficit while enjoying strong economic performance, booming investment, and high consumer welfare. Conversely, a trade surplus can just as easily reflect capital flight, suppressed consumption, and a rigid domestic market.

Treating the trade balance as a scoreboard for national success is a category mistake.

Why a category mistake? Because “the nation” doesn’t consume — people do.

You export a container of shirts and bring back a container of wine. The two ends of the deal are Chinese producers and a French vineyard. The people who actually drink the wine are Chinese; the people who actually wear the shirts are French. Both sides traded willingly because each expected to come out ahead.

The nation doesn’t “win” or “lose” in the transaction. Strip trade back to its bare form and it’s simply barter — different people in different countries swapping things.

Read more>>

Discuss on X

Subscribe to PFS recaps

New articles, pages, and podcasts. Choose how often you hear from us.

Delivery

You can change delivery or unsubscribe at any time.

Creative Commons License
Except where otherwise noted, the content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.